| Rank |
Team (1st Place Votes) |
Record |
Pts |
| 1. |
Wisconsin-Whitewater (40) |
14-1 |
1,000 |
| 2. |
Mount Union (Ohio) |
14-1 |
960 |
| 3. |
Mary Hardin Baylor (Texas) |
12-2 |
916 |
| 4. |
Bethel (Minn.) |
12-2 |
869 |
| 5. |
Wesley (Del.) |
11-2 |
802 |
| 6. |
Central (Iowa) |
12-1 |
792 |
| 7. |
St. John Fisher (N.Y.) |
11-2 |
763 |
| 8. |
Wabash (Ind.) |
11-2 |
657 |
| 9. |
St. John's (Minn.) |
10-2 |
623 |
| 10. |
Muhlenberg (Pa.) |
11-1 |
597 |
| 11. |
Case Western Reserve (Ohio) |
11-1 |
456 |
| 12. |
Washington & Jefferson (Pa.) |
10-1 |
454 |
| 13. |
Wisconsin-Eau Claire |
9-3 |
446 |
| 14. |
Trinity (Texas) |
9-2 |
398 |
| 15. |
Capital (Ohio) |
8-3 |
383 |
| 16. |
North Central (Ill.) |
9-3 |
380 |
| 17. |
Salisbury (Md.) |
9-2 |
341 |
| 18. |
St. Norbert (Wis.) |
10-1 |
340 |
| 19. |
Curry (Mass.) |
12-1 |
276 |
| 20. |
Franklin (Ind.) |
9-2 |
247 |
| 21. |
College of New Jersey |
9-3 |
219 |
| 22. |
North Carolina Wesleyan |
9-3 |
191 |
| 23. |
Mount St. Joseph (Ohio) |
9-2 |
187 |
| 24. |
Ithaca (N.Y.) |
8-3 |
129 |
| 25. |
Wartburg (Iowa) |
8-2 |
127 |