Year Name, School
2011 - Matt Evans, New Hampshire
2010 - J.C. Sherritt, Eastern Washington
2009 - Arthur Moats, James Madison
2008 - Greg Peach, Eastern Washington
2007 - Kroy Biermann, Montana
2006 - Kyle Shotwell, Cal Poly
2005 - Chris Gocong, Cal Poly
2004 - Jordan Beck, Cal Poly
2003 - Jared Allen, Idaho State
2002 - Rashean Mathis, Bethune-Cookman
2001 - Derrick Lloyd, James Madison
2000 - Edgerton Hartwell, Western Illinois
1999 - Al Lucas, Troy State
1998 - James Milton, Western Illinois
1997 - Chris McNeil, North Carolina A&T
1996 - Dexter Coakley, Appalachian State
1995 - Dexter Coakley, Appalachian State